Guide:Premium Bow Comparison v1.09, by AllNamesRTaken
- Patch: v1.09
- Gametype: PvE/PvM and PvP
- Class: Not class-specific
- Specialisation: Bowazons or any bow user
- Author: AllNamesRTaken
Contents
Physical DamageEdit
Clvl - | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 99 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 200% | 102-293 | 102-318 | 102-343 | 102-368 | 102-393 | 102-415,5 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 150% | 85-265 | 85-292 | 85-315 | 85-340 | 85-365 | 85-387,5 |
Eaglehorn | - | - | 48-281.6 | 48-294,4 | 48-307,2 | 48-318,7 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 200% | - | - | 35,5-241,4 | 35,5-241,4 | 35,5-241,4 | 35,5-241,4 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 300% | - | - | 40-272 | 40-272 | 40-272 | 40-272 |
Lycander's Aim 150% | 75-155 | 75-155 | 75-155 | 75-155 | 75-155 | 75-155 |
Lycander's Aim 200% | 85-176 | 85-176 | 85-176 | 85-176 | 85-176 | 85-176 |
M'avina's Caster | - | - | 40-201 | 40-201 | 40-201 | 40-201 |
Windforce | - | - | - | 38-491 | 38-522 | 38-550,3 |
Speed GainEdit
Amount of Shots per 10 seconds, at the maximum possible 25 frames per second
IAS - | 0 | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 100 | 110 | 120 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 1.09* | 18 | - | - | 19 | - | - | 21 | - | 21 | - | - | - | - |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 1.08** | 17 | - | - | 18 | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Eaglehorn | 17 | 18 | 19 | 21 | 23 | - | 24 | - | 25 | ||||
Hydra Bow | 17 | - | 20 | - | 23 | - | 25 | 25 | 26 | - | 28 | - | 29 |
Lycander's Aim*** | 20 | 23 | - | 24 | - | - | - | 29 | 29 | - | - | - | - |
M'avina's Caster**** | 23x | - | 25 | 25 | - | 28 | - | 28 | - | 29 | 29 | - | - |
* = + 80% IAS
** = + 50% IAS
*** = + 20% IAS
**** = + 40% IAS
Speed & Damage ComparisonEdit
Formula used: shots per 10 seconds * (Physical Damage + Elemental Damage)
Table 1: No IAS boni, other than natural speed boni on the weapons | ||||||
Clvl - | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 99 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 200% | 2412-8802 | 2412-9252 | 2412-9702 | 2412-10152 | 2412-10602 | 2412-11007 |
Windforce | - | - | - | 760-9820 | 760-10440 | 760-11006 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 150% | 2106-8298 | 2106-8784 | 2106-9198 | 2106-9648 | 2106-10098 | 2106-10503 |
Eaglehorn | - | - | 816-4787 | 816-5004 | 816-5219 | 816-5418 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 200% | - | - | 604-4104 | 604-4104 | 604-4104 | 604-4104 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 300% | - | - | 680-4624 | 680-4624 | 680-4624 | 680-4624 |
Lycander's Aim 150% | 1900-4100 | 1900-4100 | 1900-4100 | 1900-4100 | 1900-4100 | 1900-4100 |
Lycander's Aim 200% | 2200-4520 | 2200-4520 | 2200-4520 | 2200-4520 | 2200-4520 | 2200-4520 |
M'avina's Caster | - | - | 920-4623 | 920-4623 | 920-4623 | 920-4623 |
Table 2: 80% IAS (Including the natural speed boni) | ||||||
Clvl - | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 99 |
Windforce | - | - | - | 950-12275 | 950-13050 | 950-13758 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 200% | 2412-8802 | 2412-9252 | 2412-9702 | 2412-10152 | 2412-10602 | 2412-11007 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 150% | 2106-8298 | 2106-8784 | 2106-9198 | 2106-9648 | 2106-10098 | 2106-10503 |
Eaglehorn | - | - | 1200-7040 | 1200-7360 | 1200-7680 | 1200-7968 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 300% | - | - | 1040-7072 | 1040-7072 | 1040-7072 | 1040-7072 |
Lycander's Aim 200% | 2940-6328 | 2940-6328 | 2940-6328 | 2940-6328 | 2940-6328 | 2940-6328 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 200% | - | - | 923-6276 | 923-6276 | 923-6276 | 923-6276 |
Lycander's Aim 150% | 2660-5740 | 2660-5740 | 2660-5740 | 2660-5740 | 2660-5740 | 2660-5740 |
M'avina's Caster | - | - | 1040-5226 | 1040-5226 | 1040-5226 | 1040-5226 |
Table 3: Average Damage @ 80% IAS Formula: (Minimum Damage + Maximum Damage) /2 = Average Damage | ||||||
Clvl - | 50 | 60 | 70 | 80 | 90 | 99 |
Windforce | - | - | 6612 | 7000 | 7354 | |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 200% | 5607 | 5832 | 6057 | 6282 | 6507 | 6710 |
Buriza-Do Kyanon 150% | 5202 | 5445 | 5652 | 5877 | 6102 | 6305 |
Lycander's Aim 200% | 4634 | 4634 | 4634 | 4634 | 4634 | 4634 |
Eaglehorn | - | - | 4120 | 4280 | 4440 | 4584 |
Lycander's Aim 150% | 4200 | 4200 | 4200 | 4200 | 4200 | 4200 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 300% | - | - | 4056 | 4056 | 4056 | 4056 |
Cruel Hydra Bow 200% | - | - | 3600 | 3600 | 3600 | 3600 |
M'avina's Caste | - | - | 3133 | 3133 | 3133 | 3133 |
Notes / Discoveries / OdditiesEdit
- In-Game displayed damage differs from the correct damage, because for enhanced damage calculation 1 (one) damage has to be added to the base damage of a weapon.
example: A hydra bow with 200% ed should do 30 - 204 damage, but actually does 33 - 207 damage.
I did not take this oddity into account in my calculations because I consider it to be a bug.
- When a stack of arrows or bolts gets empty, the game automatically fetches a new stack from the player's inventory. This process slows down the shooting speed for 1-2 seconds.
- Items which have a chance on casting a spell with graphical effects when attacking can significantly slow down attacks, especially when used in combination with fast weapons.
- Please note: All values in this guide are based on Diablo II: Lord of Destruction v1.09 item stats.
SummaryEdit
Buriza-Do Kyanon - "potal! potal! Here I come!"Edit
Disadvantages:
- Crossbows are naturally much slower than bows.
- Much IAS boni are needed to achieve a noticable frame increase, 160% IAS bonus only
grants 2 more shots per 10 seconds.
Advantages:
- The Buriza comes along as a great package in natural form, with a lot of essential amazon mods such as
100% piercing, 80% increased attack speed, decent cold damage and more.
- Incredible damage per time factor, only beaten by a windforce with additional IAS.
- Allows usage of "alternative" equipment, since most essential mods are already covered on the weapon.
Summary:
- The Buriza remains a top choice for any amazon. It even beat the legendary windforce by 1 (one) damage in
natural form in this test *chuckle*
- The added 32-196 cold damage is a valuable companion in hell difficulty, home of many pesky physically
immune monsters.
- 100% piercing helps saving skill points and allows using a belt other than razortail.
- The natural 80% IAS on the weapon, along with the small boni from more IAS invite to not focus on popular
IAS equipment (twitchthroe etc), but rather go for damage reduction gear (Shaftstop etc).
Lycander's Aim - "Surprise, Surprise!"Edit
Advantages:
- High Natural Speed along with high gains from IAS items
- Highest minimum damage
- Low Price
Disadvantages:
- Low Maximum Damage
Summary:
- This weapon pretty surprised me during the tests. Although M'avina's Caster remains the naturally fastest
weapon (except for a row of irrelevant low-level unique bows and non-set/non-unique bows), Lycander's Aim beats it, starting at 70% IAS bonus, Lycander's bow fires 29 times over a 10 second period, where M'avina's bow is still stuck at 28, making it a top-choice pvp weapon, also because of the high minimum damage, which often leads to single-shot kills.
- Recommended to focus on IAS gear with this bow, should be socketed with shael rune.
- Mana leech on the bow allows wearing easier to find/cheaper to buy single-leech items.
- The skill boni do not provide significant benefits
M'avina's Caster - "Which Arrow killed you?" - "All of them!"Edit
Advantages:
- Although greatly increased, still decent speed gains from IAS items
- Fastest bow until 70% IAS
Disadvantages:
- Damage cannot keep up with other tested bows at higher character levels
Summary:
- Recommended using it in combination with other m'avina's items
- Top-Choice pvp weapon, although Lycander's Aim works better unless you go for damage reduction gear.
Eaglehorn - "Is that a windforce??"Edit
Advantages:
- Sufficient damage, speed, and speed gains
Disadvantages;
- High Price
Summary:
- Its ignore target defense mod makes up for the relatively low minimum damage
- A Top-Choice bow for the cow level in hell difficulty
- Recommended using in combination with an amplify damage item
Windforce - "show me plz, show me!!"Edit
Advantages:
- Great Damage, Great Speed
- Perfect for bragging, showing off, earning cash
Disadvantages:
- Insane Price
Summary:
- Mana Leech allows using easier to find/cheaper to buy single-leech items
- Knockback keeps them pesky cows away from you, and lets you use gloves other than cleglaw's pincers
- Strength bonus (10) makes it easier meeting the 134 strength requirements
- The ultimate pvm bow
Cruel Hydra Bow - "Buriza up my ass!"Edit
Advantages:
- Decent Speed
- Magic item, therefore allows more sockets than any of the other tested bows
- Good all-rounder
Disadvantages
- Lack of useful mods, other than the high ed% ;)
Summary
- Recommended using in combination with amplify damage item
- Gets useful above 250% ed
CreditsEdit
Shazam, for assistance on actually understanding all this stuff I wrote about
Ceph, for lending me some of his bows
Coca Cola Inc., for keeping me awake